The Book Thief

Yesterday I went to the cinema as I often do on a Tuesday morning, one of the benefits of working from home.  Usually the cinema is empty with the staff outnumbering the movie-goers but not yesterday.

The cinema is exactly 12 minutes walk away and there are usually 15 minutes of trailers before the film starts so I cut things fine and leave home about 2 minutes before the trailers start as there aren’t many variables on the way.  This time though there was a small queue of people buying tickets and when I made it into the auditorium of the screening I was seeing, there was around 20 people inside.  20 people at 11am?  ‘Why isn’t everyone at work?’ I wondered.  I pondered how unusual it was just in before the film started, it was The Book Thief.

The film is based on a best-selling book by Markus Zusak but it was all new to me though I did know the basics.  However the basics in this case were in no way shape or form to do justice to this great film.

The film is narrated by ‘Death’ which is a nice touch and immediately rather reminded me of old Swedish The Seventh Seal but in the end he turned out to be more lovable, rather like ‘Death’ in the Terry Pratchett tv-movies but without the sense humour.

The story is about a young blonde German girl named Leisel Meminger, she is on a long train journey when her young brother dies and is buried in a remote snowy village.  After the burial, Leisel picks up a book she sees on the ground and resumes her journey.  It transpires that Leisel is being adopted as her family as suspected of being communists, not the best thing in the world in pre-war Nazi Germany.  Her new family are impoverished and the mother is strict and tough and seems to be into adoption for some sort of financial rewards whilst her husband is warm, kind and comforting.

Geoffrey Rush as Hans Hubermann

Geoffrey Rush as Hans Hubermann

It takes a while for Leisel to adopt to her new surroundings, she misses her family and her brother and her adoptive mother is unwaveringly harsh on her.  She is also bullied at school but makes friends with her neighbour Rudy, a young handsome Aryan boy who immediately takes a fancy to her and is upset that she won’t kiss him.

Liesel and Rudy find fun despite the war.

Liesel and Rudy find fun despite the war.

Leisel’s new Dad starts reading with her on the book she brought with her.  It is a guide to being a good funeral-director but Leisel is thrilled by it and they read it every night, starting it again once they finish it.    Her Dad, Hans Hubermann converts the basement into a play area for Leisel and together they make a large dictionary, writing words all over the walls as Leisel gets to be a better reader.

War is looming in Europe and the children and locals alike are groomed into being good Nazis with Tommy Muller not just being the school bully but also the local Nazi Youth flagbearer.   Rudy however is different and longs to be as great a runner as Jesse Owens, unaware of how wrong it is for a white boy to look up to a black man and in 1930’s Germany, how dangerous it is too.  Tommy makes the pair throw books on a fire along with the other villagers though both are hugely reluctant and Leisel even comes back afterwards to retrieve a book.

Nazi Book Burning

The local parade ends up being a Nazi rally and book-burning party

 

 

 

Britain declares war on Germany and the ‘Death’ muses on how the teenagers are running excitedly to fight but are in reality running to meet him.  Leisel’s home-town becomes impoverished and her mother, Rosa Hubermann, has taken to washing and ironing the clothes of the local mayor and Leisel is amazed to see their family library and becomes friends with the mayors wife who invites her to come back and read at any time until her husband finds out and puts an end to it.

With war raging and German Jews being rounded up, a stranger called Max seeks sanctuary at the Hubermanns as Hans had his life saved by Max’s father in WW1.  Max is ill and sleeps in the shared attic with Leisel.  Harbouring a Jew in the house would have been punishable by death and so Rosa becomes even more strict as she is worried that Leisel will spill the beans.

Rudy Steiner blacks up to emulate his idol, Jesse Owens

Rudy Steiner blacks up to emulate his idol, Jesse Owens

Max and Leisel strike up a friendship and in the winter of 1941 and Hans helps the pair smuggle snow down into the basement where they have a snowball fight and build a snowman, even Rosa joins in.  However the basement is cold at the best of times and the whole thing makes Max ill again until he is at deaths door.  Leisel takes it on herself to read to Max to make him better but she has no books, instead she goes to the mayors house and sneaks in through the windows to borrow books which she reads to him.

Books

Leisel finds more books than she has ever seen before

This goes on for some time until Rudi catches her in the act and makes her feeling so guilty for keeping so many secrets from her best friend.   Just when he finds out the truth, Tommy Muller the Kinder-fuhrer passes by and wants to know what is going on.  Tommy and Rudy fight and Leisels precious book goes flying into the river.  Rudy later goes and collects it but it takes a while and Leisel thinks he has drowned.   Rudy promised never to tell anyone of the secret and he is as good as his word.

Leisel and Max

Leisel reading stories to Max

The next day the local Nazi soldiers turn up to search the cellars and with a lot of luck, Max is hidden behind a drooping Nazi flag. The house-hold is always under suspicion as Hans refused to become a member of the National-Socialist Party.

The war goes on and Rudy’s dad is forced to join up into the army.  The town is now being bombed from the air which terrifies everyone except for a recovered Max as with everyone under cover it allows him a few brief minutes of freedom and fresh air.

When Hans is in the street and sees a Jewish shopkeeper being dragged away he intercedes and tells the officer that he has known the man for years and his son is fighting in the German Army.  Hans is beaten and his name is taken which sets off a series of events leading to Max fleeing for his life.

Rudy runs away and wants to take Leisel with him.  He has been earmarked for elite training and must leave next year.  There is a funny and touching scene where they both shout out over a beautiful lake how they hate Hitler.

Things take a turn for the worse Hans is called up despite his age, it is a mark of how badly things are now going for Germany.   Leisel is distraught, having lost her original family, then Max now her father and soon Rudy too.  At least Rosa has now opened up a little and reveals that underneath that tough exterior is a warm hearted mother even though she admits she is a witch.

Hans in the army

Leisel hugs her adoptive father with his army uniform on.

Max is seriously injured in the war and is invalided out and for a while everything is ok before ‘Death’ returns one last time.  An Allied bombing run accidentally hits the wrong target and the whole of their street is bombed.  Everyone is killed except for Leisel and Rudy but Rudy too quickly dies moments after his body is recovered and never quite finishes his “I love you” moment.  Leisel tries to kiss him before it is too late… she is too late and she collapses only to be found by the mayors wife who takes her in.

A few years later, Leisel is working in the shop belonging to Rudy’s father who happily made it through the war.  A tall dark stranger walks in through the front door.  It is Max he made it too and from ‘Deaths’ point of view it seems they both lived out a happy life overlooking Central Park in New York but having never forgotten the family and friends taken from them in the war, especially the lemon haired boy Rudy.

I thought the film to be amazing with a hint of ‘Life is Beautiful’ and ‘The Boy in Striped Pyjamas’ but only slightly so as it was really about a young girl in a poor family trying to get by in the most difficult of circumstances.  It was a very moving film and the last 45 minutes the auditorium was filled by sniffling from around the darkness.

The relationships between Leisel and Rudy and also Max were hugely moving as it was with Hans and on those few moments Rosa let her real self show through it was very touching.

There were several funny moments and the scene where they talked about how all mothers love their children, even Hitlers, as Max and Leisel imagine what she must say to her awful son was hilarious and one which I hoped would happen when the scene first started.

It was also tragic in places as it was so clear the Rudy was anything but a Nazi and when Leisel heard her adoptive mother belittle her and her mother, dashing her dreams as she thought it was the realistic way to proceed.  Most of all though when ‘Death’ came that last time which was heart-breaking.

All the actors did an amazing job and Geoffrey Rush is always dependable and likeable.  Young Marie-Sophie Nelisse from Canada was terrific as Leisel as was Emily Watson and Nico Liersch the young German who played Rudy.

It’s amazing just how distant WW2 now is.  Bring 40 I am of an age that doesn’t at all remember it but does very much remember what it was like in post-war Britain in the dire 70’s and the war looming over everything.  It’s incredible how those 10 or 20 years younger don’t have any of that and I think films like this are great at reminding them as well as being excellent stories in their own right.  It also gives an insight of what life could be like again if things turn out badly or how it must be for people living in less fortunate lands.

When the film finished, everyone sat in silence which rarely happens.  The titles rolled and when the lights came on it was just I and two older women left, the rest running out with their hankies no doubt.  I turned round and said to them that “it was a good film wasn’t it”.  “It makes you think” was their reply.  I walked back home thinking ‘It certainly does’.

This post is dedicated to my Granddad, Harold Heard, who fought in WW2 and would have been celebrating his 98th birthday today on 5th March.  I’m sure he would have loved the film as much as I did.

The Book Thief Movie Poster

The Book Thief Movie Poster

Advertisements

About Stephen Liddell

I am a writer and traveller with a penchant for history and getting off the beaten track. With several books to my name including a #1 seller, I also write environmental, travel and history articles for magazines as well as freelance work. Recently I've appeared on BBC Radio and Bloomberg TV and am waiting on the filming of a ghost story on British TV. I run my own private UK tours company (Ye Olde England Tours) with small, private and totally customisable guided tours run by myself!
This entry was posted in history, Movies and Films, Popular Culture, WW2 and tagged , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

24 Responses to The Book Thief

  1. EBotziou says:

    I thought the book was brilliant so I can’t wait to see the film. Lovely dedication to your Grandfather 🙂

    Like

    • The film is truly brilliant and the most moving I have seen for years. The first really good film of 2014.

      Thank-you, I hope he would be pleased 🙂 He was rather like Hans in the film though Grandma was definitely not like Rosa.

      Like

  2. Diane Tibert says:

    Reblogged this on Diane Tibert and commented:
    SPOILER ALERT: The complete line is revealed in this wonderful post, so if you plan to watch the movie, don’t read this. I don’t expect to see the movie for a few years, and will have forgotten the details, so it does me no harm.

    – Diane Tibert

    Like

  3. Diane Tibert says:

    Thank you for sharing. I have heard from others that it is a wonderful film. When I get the chance to see it in the future on DVD I will watch.

    That war does seem far away. I was born in the 60s, tenth of eleven children by a man who served in the war in Italy and Holland. What happened during the war years seems like another world, but as you say it is reality for some today in war-torn countries.

    Here in Nova Scotia it seems we talk more about the First World War. It is because every year we mark the Halifax Explosion which devastated the cities of Halifax and Dartmouth. I’ve walked into a cemetery many times and saw more than one headstone etched with that fateful December day.

    Like

    • Hello Diane,
      I am so glad that you like my posting. I too will have to watch it on DVD. It is so nice to find a new film that is such a delight to enjoy amongst all the other lesser movies. Nice to see the innocent friendships too of all those in the film and showing the stupidity of the war and Hitlers ideas in particular.

      It is funny how much life has changed, looking back life was much more like the 1914 than 2014.

      That was such an incredible explosion and it killed so many people, it is no wonder it continues to be a focus for people. It is much the same here depending on the locality and the casualties in each place. I think WW1 had a much bigger and more negative impact than WW2 which though terrible and desperate particularly for many has rather pushed The Great War into the shadows due to the Hollywood films on WW2. Hitler and the Nazis were such good material for films in the 60’s and 70’s.

      I hope the looming centenary of World War One will bring it back to the forefront. I enjoyed Warhorse, a nice if light WW1 film.

      Like

  4. The Book Thief is one of the best books I’ve ever read. I haven’t seen the movie (yet) but recommend that you read the book as well.

    Like

  5. merrildsmith says:

    I haven’t seen the movie, which was out here in the US a couple of months ago. I will probably see it on DVD soon. The book was wonderful, and it seems the movie is somewhat different. I think the book will also make you think. 🙂
    Lovely tribute to your grandfather. My parents married during WWII and both did “war work.” My mom for a while was not “Rosie the Riveter” but the woman on the opposite side of the riveter.

    Like

    • I’m surprised that the film didn’t win any Oscars but often the ones that win aren’t the ones I enjoy the most. Gravity was great for what it was but it wasn’t like The Book Thief.

      I’ve heard the book and movie are different which will be nice for me so long as the relationships are similar.

      It’s wonderful that people carried on getting married and going about their lives under such testing circumstances.

      Being on the opposite side of the riveter was just as important as being on the front-line in its own way. Its amazing what we can do when everyone can unite for the same goal and such a shame it only ever seems to happen in the bad times.

      I am still thinking about the movie now, 24 hours later 🙂

      Like

      • merrildsmith says:

        I will definitely see the movie. I thought it looked good from the trailers (I like trailers). I didn’t see Gravity either, but I agree there are always movies that should at least have been nominated that aren’t. I tend to see a lot of the smaller indie films that rarely get chosen.

        I remember my dad telling me that he volunteered for the service after Pearl Harbor, but his eyesight was just too bad. My mom said they had a very simple wedding and she did not wear a gown because it didn’t seem right during the war.

        Like

        • I don’t mind the film trailers if they are for good movies as they do help you find the best-releases but I always try and miss the commercials we have before the trailers. I have better things to do than spend money to watch advertising I get for free at home 🙂

          There looks some really good films coming out with only Spiderman 2 not looking my sort of thing. I like Indie films too and it can be hard to find them.

          In Britain no churchbells were allowed to be rung during the war as they were kept to be used as an alarm if we were invaded. My other Grandparents got married just after the war and it was the first time the church bells had been rung in 6 years. I bet the whole place turned out to see it no matter how modest it was.

          Like

          • merrildsmith says:

            I think I knew that about the church bells, but what a cool story about your grandparents. I love it.

            Yes, I agree about the commercials at the movies. It seems to have gotten worse in the last few years.

            Like

  6. Oh I am sooo going to watch this! Thanks for the review! :’)

    Like

  7. CMrok93 says:

    Good review Stephen. Could have been a lot worse, but then again, could have been a lot better as well. Still, wasn’t nearly as bad as some of the other, Holocaust-themed movies I’ve seen in the past. Especially those that somehow find themselves being released around Oscar-time.

    Like

    • Thank-you Dan.

      I am not a fan of many of the Holocaust-themed movies either, perhaps this one escapes that problem by focusing on the general lives of the children rather than the horrors of the concentration camps.

      Like

  8. Rosemarie says:

    I haven’t seen the movie, but I did read the book. Not the best in my opinion, but an interesting concept.

    Like

    • If you didn’t like the book, I can’t say that you should see the film but I did really enjoy it.

      The concept was interesting, what I enjoyed the most was the importance of literature and also the innocence and determination of the children to have fun.

      Like

  9. Thanks for your positive review of “The Book Thief.” In the U.S. it received negative reviews and did not do well at the box office, but I thoroughly enjoyed the film. You say that “Marie-Sophie Nelisse from Canada was terrific as Leisel.” I agree and thought she was gorgeous. On the 27th of this month she turns 14 and lives with her family in Montreal.

    Like

    • Before I wrote my review I checked out some of the professional reviews of the film and was really surprised that it did so badly.

      I couldn’t change my mind though, I whole-heartedly enjoyed this movie and found it a pleasant change from the usual teenage comedy films, quirky road movies or hollywood blockbusters.

      As soon as I saw Marie-Sophie Nelisse I thought what a cute girl she is and it is. She did a great job with her performance overall at such a young ageand with the accent too. I was expecting her to be German.

      The actor who played Rudy also did well with his English given his age. I could really buy into their friendship.

      I do hope they go on to have good careers but even at this stage it is hard to imagine them finding a better movie to appear in.

      Like

  10. I am sorry that I missed the Book Thief in Canada, hoping I will catch it soon as I absolutely loved the book. I was lucky enough to hear Marcus Zusack talk at the Sydney Writer’s Festival about the process of writing – long before there was talk to making the film. I understand that he was very involved in the making of the film which is perhaps why it was so true to the book.

    Like

  11. Genuine Poetry says:

    great post! I just watched the movie last night and found the girl and Max very endearing characters. I love the way the movie ended inspiring us to become writers.

    Like

  12. Pingback: The Fault In Our Stars | Stephen Liddell

  13. Pingback: The Top Movies and TV Shows of 2014 | Stephen Liddell

A blog is nothing with out feedback, please give me some!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s